The University of Southampton’s council is believed to be “reviewing its position” on plans to hold a controversial academic conference on Israel’s legitimacy.
The claim was made by Vivian Wineman, head of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, a group representing the interests of British Jews, after a meeting with Vice-Chancellor Don Nutbeam calling to cancel the conference.
Mr Wineman said:
We put forward very strong concerns. The conference is formulated in extremist terms, has attracted toxic speakers and is likely to result in an increase in antisemitism and tension on campus.
The University is reviewing its position and is considering all the options open to it.
The conference, scheduled for 17th-19th April, titled “International Law and the State of Israel: Legitimacy, Responsibility and Exceptionalism”, has received significant criticism since it was announced earlier this month.
The Zionist Federation labelled it a ‘kangaroo court’, and a petition with over 4,500 signatures calling for the event’s cancellation said the conference “will legitimize the harmful message that Israel’s very existence is up for debate.”
Some university students have demanded that the event be cancelled on the grounds that “Southampton must not be allowed to become a platform for hatred”, and that the University’s “attempt to weigh in on this is a pointless and offensive endeavour”.
Southampton North MP Caroline Nokes said the University would be “potentially bring itself into disrepute by hosting such an apparently one-sided event”.
A spokesperson for the University told the Jewish Chronicle:
“[The University] very much values its relationships with students, staff, visitors and invited speakers from Israel and the Jewish community.
We will do all we can within our statutes and ordinances to ensure that any distress or upset is addressed.”
Should the conference go ahead or be cancelled? Let us know what you think in the comments below.
UoS doesn’t have a “board” – it has Senate and Council. I think you might be mixing terms between The Board of Deputies of British Jews and the University?
other than that, solid article.
Reply
Noted and changed, thanks.
Reply
Except in the headline, you mean?
Reply
Disgusting cowardice from UoS.
Reply
“Reviewing their options”
Well, they have 2:
1) Let the conference go ahead. Get some intense but very temporary flack from the Israeli lobby. Bad press for the university. The conference goes ahead.
2) Order the conference to find another venue, demonstrating that the university is willing to abandon its responsibility to promote and defend academic freedom as soon as it becomes inconvenient. Bad press for the university. The conference goes ahead.
Bear in mind option 2 probably violates university policy and Don Nutbeam is retiring in a few months and you get the feeling that there is only one likely outcome.
Reply
Ban free speech, controversial opinions should be contained lest someone gets offended ;_;
Reply
im going and i hope UoS stands its ground and are not bullied by the jewish community who yet again are pulling the race card.
Reply
This conference was ever intended to be a ‘kangeroo court’ or an excuse for rampant ‘anti-semitism’, just an interesting academic debate concerning contemporary issues, and now the uni are being bullied out of holding it! It’ll be a sad day for freedom of speech if this gets cancelled. Stand your ground Southampton Uni!
Reply
never*
Reply